Brooke Rollins runs the Department of Agriculture. Last year she called screwworm "terrifying." This year she's calling it a "little pest." The screwworm has not changed its behavior. Rollins has changed her talking points.
Screwworm is a parasitic fly larva that burrows into living flesh and eats animals from the inside out. Cattle ranchers lose their herds. Wildlife dies screaming. The USDA spent decades eradicating it from the United States. Now it's spreading again. Rollins looked at this situation and thought, you know what this needs? Downplaying.
The messaging pivot is clean. Terrifying becomes little pest. Apocalyptic threat becomes minor nuisance. It's the kind of rhetorical about-face that makes you wonder if Rollins got a memo from someone who thinks farmers are too worried about their livestock being devoured by maggots. Maybe focus groups said "terrifying" polls badly with swing voters. Maybe she just forgot what screwworms do.
Retail traders will see this headline and think it contains actionable intelligence about agricultural commodity futures. They will open positions based on whether the Secretary sounds scared enough. They will lose money because screwworms don't care about USDA press strategy and neither do cattle futures. The larva keeps eating. The market keeps moving. Rollins keeps workshopping her adjectives.
She could have said nothing. She could have maintained a consistent position on flesh-eating parasites. Instead we get a masterclass in how to undermine your own credibility in under twelve months. Last year's terrifying crisis is this year's little pest, and next year it'll probably be a "minor administrative challenge" right before someone's entire herd gets consumed by fly larvae.
Brooke Rollins just taught every government flack in America that you can say whatever the f*ck you want as long as you wait long enough between statements.
Photo by on Unsplash
Leave a Comment