Will Cathcart is stepping down as head of WhatsApp. He's not leaving Meta. He's just moving to another role at the company, which is what happens when you successfully manage a product with two billion users and zero revenue strategy anyone can explain. They promote you sideways.
Kunal Shah will replace him. Shah founded CRED, an Indian fintech app that rewards people for paying their credit card bills on time. The business model is giving people points for doing what they were already legally obligated to do. It's like getting a trophy for showing up to your own court date.
Cathcart ran WhatsApp for years without monetizing it into oblivion, which by Meta standards makes him a f*cking saint. He kept the product clean. No ads between your mom's good morning texts. No marketplace tab selling counterfeit Nikes. Just encryption and group chats where your extended family argues about politics. He did his job and now he's being rewarded with a role nobody will remember in six months.
Shah comes in with fintech credentials, which means Meta is absolutely going to jam payments and commerce down WhatsApp's throat until it chokes. They tried this before in India. It didn't work. But now they have a guy who built an app that gamifies fiscal responsibility, so surely this time will be different.
The press release will say innovation. It will say global expansion. It will say synergy, because corporate communications departments are legally required to use that word twice per quarter. What it means is Meta looked at WhatsApp's user base and decided it's time to extract value from people who just wanted to send messages without Zuckerberg's algorithm deciding what they see.
Cathcart gets a golden parachute that doesn't involve jumping out of anything. Shah gets to explain to two billion users why they now earn points for texting their friends. Retail traders will somehow find a way to lose money on this news anyway.
Photo by on Unsplash
Leave a Comment