Amazon decided to offer its trucking capacity to outside shippers. Freight stocks dropped like a retail trader's port after discovering options expire.
The company spent years building a logistics network to avoid paying FedEx and UPS. Turns out when you own tens of thousands of trucks and they're not always full, you can sell the empty space to other people. Revolutionary stuff. Maersk executives are presumably in a conference room right now pretending they saw this coming.
Traditional freight brokers make money by standing between shippers and truckers while adding no value whatsoever. Amazon can do the same thing except they actually own the trucks. And the warehouses. And the planes. And probably the roads soon enough.
The market sold off XPO Logistics, C.H. Robinson, and every other middleman whose business model is "we know a guy with a truck." Investors finally grasped that competing against a company with infinite capital and a pathological need to dominate every adjacent market is not a winning strategy.
Retail traders bought the dip because they read one headline about shipping rates staying elevated. They did not read the part where Amazon can undercut every incumbent by thirty percent and still turn a profit. They never read that part.
The beautiful irony is these freight companies spent decades telling investors their relationships were their moat. Their customer relationships. Their carrier relationships. Turns out relationships matter less when someone shows up with better prices and a platform that doesn't run on software from 2007.
C.H. Robinson has been a freight broker since 1905. They had a hundred and twenty years to build a truck fleet. They chose not to. Amazon had fifteen years and built one anyway. One of these companies will exist in a decade. The other will be a case study titled "We Thought Being Old Was a Competitive Advantage."
Photo by on Unsplash
Leave a Comment