E.l.f. Beauty got $50 million back from the government. Profits doubled. The company sells makeup that costs less than a sandwich.
Let me walk you through this. E.l.f. paid tariffs. Then E.l.f. got a refund on those tariffs. Then profits surged 100%. Retail traders saw the headline and bought shares because numbers went up. They did not ask which numbers or why or whether a one-time refund might be, you know, one time.
The best part is calling this a windfall. A windfall is when money falls from the sky. This money fell from a filing cabinet in a customs office after E.l.f.'s lawyers filled out forms for eighteen months. Same thing, I guess.
Tariff refunds are not recurring revenue. They are the opposite of recurring revenue. They are the government saying "my bad, here's your money back" and then never saying it again. But the stock moved like E.l.f. invented a new eyeliner that cures diabetes.
Someone bought calls at the top today. Probably several someones. They saw "profits surge 100%" and their brain released enough dopamine to override the part that reads footnotes. That part would have mentioned the $50 million refund. It would have mentioned fiscal quarters. It would have mentioned that subtraction exists.
The company sells lip gloss. The government gave them $50 million. Analysts will now spend six weeks modeling this into forward guidance as if customs refunds are a sustainable growth vertical.
Next quarter when profits don't double, those same analysts will downgrade the stock and blame macroeconomic headwinds instead of admitting they can't subtract $50 million from a balance sheet.
Photo by on Unsplash
Leave a Comment