Athleta comparable sales fell 15%. Gap shares rose more than 11%. Investors looked at that and bought. Fine.
Here is the situation. Gap named Ashley Kechter the new CEO of Athleta. She starts December 14. She comes from Vuori, where she was global president. She also used to work at Gap, Old Navy and Banana Republic. So Gap did not hire a stranger. Gap hired an ex.
Her predecessor, Maggie Gauger, left for Lululemon in October. Gap lost its Athleta CEO to the competition. Then it hired one from a different competition. Athleisure is the only business where the staff does laps.
Gap CEO Richard Dickson told CNBC he is "disappointed" with Athleta. Athleta net sales fell 14% to $220 million. That is a quarter of leggings, and nobody wanted them. Dickson called Kechter's skills "clarity and conviction." Athleta needs those. It also needs customers.
Now Old Navy. Comparable sales were flat. Flat. The headline calls this "signs of progress." Last quarter they fell 4%. Zero is better than negative four. By that standard, my brokerage account is a turnaround story. Old Navy's new CEO, Michael Francis, started this month. He has already been credited with progress. Impressive, given that he has done nothing yet.
Overall comparable sales were flat. Wall Street wanted up 1.3%. Revenue came in at $4.01 billion against a $4.02 billion estimate. Gap missed by about ten million dollars. Gap also cut its full-year forecast. The stock jumped anyway, because earnings per share hit 82 cents against 78. Four cents of beat. Four pennies. Retail traders will mortgage a kidney for four pennies.
The Gap brand itself rose 9%. That is the twelfth straight quarter of growth. Good for the Gap brand. Nobody will remember that by Monday.
If you bought Gap Friday morning on the Old Navy turnaround, congratulations on your flat comp. Frame it next to the Athleta leggings you will never wear.
Photo by on Unsplash

Leave a Comment