,

Blue Wave Hits 10th Place, Investors Asked to Hold Applause


A CNBC analysis of historical election data finds wave elections don't necessarily spell trouble for the party in power during the next presidential year.

  •   1 min read
Blue Wave Hits 10th Place, Investors Asked to Hold Applause

CNBC dug through elections back to 1938 to ask whether a midterm wave predicts the next presidential race. ,The answer: "Statistically, the answer is it should have little effect.",

Sixty-eight years of data. Zero usable conclusions.

The wave itself is a modest one. ,It ranks 10th in CNBC's analysis, using an estimate of 41 House seats gained by the opposition party., Tenth. The bronze medal has two more people ahead of it.

The headline calls it a blue wave. The data calls it a wave the way a puddle is a lake.

The history is no help either. ,The biggest loss came in 1938, when Democrats lost 72 House seats, under Franklin Roosevelt. ,Of the top four wave elections before a president's final term, the incumbent won reelection each time., So the party that got waved on kept the White House. Good luck building a trade on that.

CNBC also borrowed surfer slang. ,A wave that lasts a long time is a "runner.", Now the question is whether this one runs. The article is for investors, which means someone out there will buy a 2028 election contract because a surfer metaphor felt good.

Even the Democratic pollster at Hart Associates, Jay Campbell, undercuts the whole premise. ,"If candidate quality matters in congressional elections, it matters 1,000 times more in presidential ones.", Translation: the candidate matters more than the wave. Nobody has picked a candidate. The 2028 map is a blank sheet and a prayer.

Over at Inside Elections, the forecast is a coin flip with better vocabulary. ,Best case, 2026 starts a two-cycle wave like 2006 and 2008. Or 2028 could resemble 2012., Two outcomes. Pick one. You'll be right half the time, which beats your options trading.

Retail traders will still price this in by Monday. They'll call it a thesis. It's a tide chart read by people who've never seen an ocean.

The wave tells you nothing about 2028, and neither does your cousin's Discord.

Photo by Element5 Digital on Unsplash

Related Posts

↑

The Noise is free. If Phil's commentary made you laugh or think, he accepts tips. No pressure — the sarcasm was complimentary.

Leave a Tip