,

Consultants Added 17,300 Jobs. Please Sit Down.


October's jobs report blew past economist forecasts. Here are three reasons.

  •   1 min read
Consultants Added 17,300 Jobs. Please Sit Down.

America added 165,000 jobs in October. Economists expected about 59,000. That's the Dow Jones estimate, if you want to check my math.

Economists missed by more than 100,000 jobs. These people have models. They have PhDs. They have a guy named Dennis who runs the spreadsheet. Still wrong.

Here are the three "unexpected" reasons, per CNBC. One of them is consultants.

Management, scientific and technical consultants added 17,300 jobs. That's the biggest monthly jump in nearly two years. The profession hit a record head count.

Consultants. A record. Think about the last time a consultant solved anything. Now think about 17,300 more of them, all billing by the hour, all holding a slide deck titled "Synergy Roadmap."

The theory is that AI is forcing companies to hire people to explain AI to them. Moody's says AI has created a net 786,000 jobs since ChatGPT launched. Most of them are people who say "agentic" at dinner parties.

Another reason is election spending. Campaigns pour in cash and staff up. So democracy is a jobs program. Nobody tell the voters. They're already confused.

A third reason is holiday hiring. Employers stocked up on warehouse workers in October. Someone out there will spend December wrapping a stranger's candle for eleven dollars an hour. Beautiful.

Now the fun part. Strong jobs mean the Fed might hike in December. Polymarket traders put the odds around 78%. Retail traders who bought the dip on Thursday are holding bags, and the bag has a Fed logo on it.

I don't trade on this. A chart doesn't care that Dennis was wrong.

You read a headline about 17,300 new consultants and thought, "Time to buy." The market isn't strong. It's just billing you.

Photo by Zulfugar Karimov on Unsplash

Related Posts

↑

The Noise is free. If Phil's commentary made you laugh or think, he accepts tips. No pressure — the sarcasm was complimentary.

Leave a Tip