,

FSA Forfeiture: Congratulations, You Overpaid Yourself Into Profit


While experts say it's best to use up your FSA money, the tax savings on your contributions could outweigh any amount you forfeit. Here's how to tell.

  •   1 min read
FSA Forfeiture: Congratulations, You Overpaid Yourself Into Profit

Lose money. Save money. Same transaction. Welcome to the Flexible Spending Account, the only financial product designed by a committee that hated both math and joy.

Here is the pitch. You hand your employer a slice of each paycheck before taxes. If you don't spend it on medical stuff by the deadline, it vanishes. The experts say use it all. The experts also say the tax break on your contributions can outweigh what you forfeit.

Read that again. You can throw money in a hole and still walk away ahead.

Run the numbers. Say you're in the 24 percent federal bracket. You stash $1,000 pre-tax. You forget about $200 of it. You lost $200. But you dodged roughly $240 in federal tax on the full thousand. Net gain: about $40, before payroll taxes make it look even better. That is the financial equivalent of tripping and landing on a twenty.

This is the system working as intended.

The rules help you ignore it. Employers can offer a grace period of a couple of months, or a limited carryover. They cannot offer both. Most workers will not check which one they have. They will find out in January, standing in a pharmacy aisle, buying nine pairs of reading glasses and a fourteen-pack of thermometers to beat the clock.

That is your retail investor, by the way. Same energy. Panic-buying at the deadline, convinced the bandaids are an appreciation play.

The article says use your money first. Good advice. Nobody will follow it. Humans cannot plan for a hernia in March, so they plan for nothing and forfeit with confidence.

The tax code has built a casino where the house takes your leftover chips and still sends you a thank-you card. You lose and win at once. SchrΓΆdinger's paycheck.

Enjoy your $40, champ. Spend it on the one thing the FSA won't cover: a financial plan.

Photo by Philip Veater on Unsplash

Related Posts

↑

The Noise is free. If Phil's commentary made you laugh or think, he accepts tips. No pressure β€” the sarcasm was complimentary.

Leave a Tip