The Labor Department submitted a rule proposal that could expand association health plans. These plans let small businesses band together to buy insurance. The White House has it now. Workers might pay less. Or they might not.
Association health plans already exist. They have existed for years. The proposal would let more people use them. This counts as news because a government agency filed paperwork suggesting they might do something they already do but slightly more.
The pitch is simple. Small businesses join forces. They negotiate as a group. Insurers offer lower rates because the risk pool is bigger. Retail traders will read this headline and think they cracked the code on healthcare arbitrage. They will calculate premiums in a spreadsheet. They will convince themselves this affects their portfolio. It does not.
Here is what actually happens. The rule gets proposed. It sits at the White House for months. Industry groups submit comments. Lawyers argue about definitions. The final rule emerges two years later with seventeen carve-outs and a phase-in period that spans three administrations. By then everyone has forgotten the original proposal. Insurance costs rise anyway because that is what insurance costs do.
Some workers will save money. Good for them. Some will not. Association plans can exclude pre-existing conditions depending on how the rule is written. They can offer skimpier coverage. Lower premiums sound great until you need the insurance to actually pay for something.
The real comedy is watching people treat a rule proposal as market-moving information. The Labor Department floats an idea. Financial media writes it up. Retail traders add healthcare stocks to their watchlist. The stocks do nothing. The proposal changes nothing. The cycle continues.
Your health insurance will still be expensive and you will still complain about the deductible while day-trading biotech penny stocks.
Photo by Marek Studzinski on Unsplash
Leave a Comment