Morgan Stanley beat the S&P 500 over twelve months. They refreshed the list. Retail traders will now buy these stocks at the top and blame the Fed when they tank.
The firm won't tell you which stocks made the cut until you're already three percent underwater. That's how this works. They publish the list after their clients bought six months ago. You read about it in a headline. You open Robinhood. You market-order at 9:31 AM. The stock gaps down forty minutes later. You check Reddit. Everyone says hold. You hold. Morgan Stanley publishes next year's list. Your pick isn't on it anymore.
Beating the S&P 500 sounds impressive until you remember the S&P 500 is just five hundred companies that already beat everyone else. It's like winning a participation trophy at a spelling bee for people who already won spelling bees. The bar is so high that clearing it by two percent means absolutely nothing to someone trading on margin in a taxable account.
The new members remain unnamed in this headline. That's the tell. If the stocks were good, you'd know them already. Instead you get a vague promise that Morgan Stanley—who exists to move product—has identified future winners using the same backward-looking metrics that told them to love commercial real estate in 2007.
Technical analysis says none of this matters. The chart doesn't care about analyst upgrades. Support and resistance don't read research notes. A stock that rallied twelve months will mean-revert the second you buy it, not because markets are efficient, but because you have the worst timing in human history and Morgan Stanley knows it.
Photo by Sven Piper on Unsplash
Leave a Comment