,

Nine Justices to Decide What Robinhood Forgot to Mention


The Trump administration had urged the Supreme Court to hear an appeal by Robinhood of a lower-court's decision to revive an investors' lawsuit over the IPO.

  •   2 min reads
Nine Justices to Decide What Robinhood Forgot to Mention

Nine of the most powerful legal minds in America will now study a Robinhood IPO filing. Bold use of their time.

The facts are simple. ,The Supreme Court agreed on Friday to consider an effort by Robinhood Markets to shut down a lawsuit accusing the brokerage of misleading investors about its financials and growth prospects., ,President Trump's administration had urged the Court to hear the appeal, and backed Robinhood's position.,

The lawsuit concerns July 2021. ,The IPO priced 55 million shares at $38., Investors say the paperwork left out how badly the meme-stock and crypto party was winding down. ,Quarterly revenue later fell about 35%, from $565 million to $365 million, and crypto revenue dropped roughly 78%.,

A 78% drop. In crypto revenue. At a company whose customers were buying Dogecoin because a dog was on it.

Robinhood's defense is elegant. ,It argues its IPO documents already warned shareholders about a potential slowdown after the extraordinary trading activity earlier that year., Translation: we told you the music might stop. You bought a ticket to the dance anyway.

The legal question is narrower than the drama. ,The Court limited review to one question: whether an issuer can be liable under Section 11(a) of the Securities Act for omitting material information., ,Robinhood argues an omission must be connected to a particular statement.,

Think about that. A federal court may soon rule on whether silence counts as a statement. Robinhood has been practicing silence for years. Ask anyone who tried to sell GameStop in January 2021.

The plaintiffs are not backing down. ,They say the case concerns classic half-truths in the registration statement., Half-truths. In an IPO document. Next they'll tell me the free stock wasn't free.

The defendants also include the underwriters. ,Among them are Goldman Sachs and J.P. Morgan., Two firms that have never once omitted anything.

Here's the part that matters for your portfolio. Nothing. ,A ruling is expected by the end of June., The chart will do whatever it was going to do anyway.

Retail traders who bought at $38 are now waiting on nine judges to tell them what they should have read. The filing was available the whole time. Most of them were busy reading a Reddit thread about a frog.

Photo by Maxim Hopman on Unsplash

Related Posts

↑

The Noise is free. If Phil's commentary made you laugh or think, he accepts tips. No pressure — the sarcasm was complimentary.

Leave a Tip