Retirees sometimes need cash for a one-time expense. A roof. A hip. A grandson's wedding with an open bar and no sense of shame.
So they eye the 401(k) or the IRA. Financial advisors say wait. Weigh the trade-offs first.
Fine. Weigh them.
Trade-off one: withdrawals from traditional accounts count as ordinary income. Pull out too much and you may bump yourself into a higher tax bracket. The IRS does not send a thank-you card. It sends a form.
Trade-off two: you shrink the pile that is supposed to outlive you. Money pulled out stops compounding. The market does not care that the roof leaked.
Trade-off three: timing. Sell investments in a down market and you lock in the loss. Advisors have a phrase for this. The phrase is "don't."
So the pros suggest alternatives. Check your cash reserves first. Look at other accounts. Spread the withdrawal across tax years if you can. Think before you cash out.
Revolutionary stuff. Somebody get this advice a laminated card for the waiting room.
Here is my technical read. The chart of your retirement balance is a line moving down and to the right. It was always going to move down and to the right. That is the entire point of retirement. You are a slow-motion sell order with a Medicare card.
Retail traders will read this and nod. Then they will do the opposite. They will pull the whole 401(k) for a lake house, a jet ski, and a truck that costs more than the lake.
The advisors mean well. They are paid to mean well.
Your portfolio is not a piggy bank. It is a piggy bank with a tax lawyer, and the pig is already dead.
Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash

Leave a Comment