The Clarity Act failed a cloture vote. The name of the bill was Clarity Act. The Senate blocked a bill literally named after the one thing crypto regulation does not have.
Retail traders spent eighteen months begging lawmakers to tell them whether their dog-themed tokens counted as securities. The Senate said no. Not no to the tokens. No to answering the question. The difference matters to approximately nobody who will lose money either way.
Crypto lobbyists wanted a comprehensive market framework. They hired consultants. Flew to Washington. Wore ties. Prepared PowerPoints explaining why digital tokens backed by nothing should trade freely alongside actual securities. The Senate listened politely and voted to preserve the current system, which is that nobody knows what the f*ck is legal and enforcement happens exclusively through surprise lawsuits filed at 4pm on Fridays.
The industry called this a regulatory blow. A blow implies momentum was stopped. Momentum requires movement. The crypto market framework has been a parking lot full of abandoned shopping carts since 2017. Nothing got blown anywhere. The carts are still there.
Some trader in Ohio just read this headline and panic-sold his entire position. Different trader in Nevada saw the same headline and bought the dip. Both will cite the Senate vote when explaining their strategy to their divorce attorneys next year.
The bill needed sixty votes. It did not get sixty votes. Democracy worked exactly as designed, which in this case means protecting Americans' right to remain confused about whether buying Bitcoin through a Telegram bot constitutes tax evasion, securities fraud, or neither.
Clarity remains unavailable, which means the lawyers stay employed and the regulators stay angry and the traders stay poor.
Photo by Kanchanara on Unsplash
Leave a Comment