UnitedHealth shares are behaving strangely before earnings. The stock's options are more expensive than usual. This means traders are paying a premium to bet on volatility they think is coming.
They're wrong.
Options premiums spike when fear spikes. Fear spikes when retail traders read headlines like this one and decide they've cracked the code. They haven't cracked anything except their brokerage account balance. UnitedHealth could announce they're pivoting to cryptocurrency mining and the stock would move 2%. But someone named Derek just bought $500 worth of weekly calls because he saw unusual activity on Twitter.
The summary mentions that insuring shares of health insurers costs more than health insurance itself. Cute. Also meaningless. Health insurance costs thousands per year and might save your life. Options premium costs hundreds and will definitely expire worthless while you're rage-scrolling Reddit trying to figure out what implied volatility means.
Here's what's actually happening: market makers see earnings coming and they widen the bid-ask spread because they're not idiots. Retail sees the higher premiums and thinks it means smart money knows something. Smart money knows you're about to pay 40% over fair value for a contract that decays faster than your will to check your portfolio.
UnitedHealth will report earnings. The stock will move or it won't. Everyone who paid elevated premiums will lose money except the market maker who sold them the contract at 9:31 AM and hedged it by 9:32 AM.
The only thing unusual here is that people keep falling for the same trick every earnings season like goldfish with credit cards.
Photo by on Unsplash
Leave a Comment